Wednesday, April 2, 2014

Can Amazon beat Walmart in the Retail Game?


The e-commerce market where companies such as Amazon, eBay and Alibaba operate is just 8% of the total retail market. The retail is still dominated by brick & mortar players such as Walmart, Target, Carrefour and Tesco.


After seeing this chart, you shouldn’t be surprised when you see headlines such as:


  

Ecommerce players are trying to enter traditional retail, and at the same time retailers such as Walmart and Target are improving their e-commerce experience.  Even though total retail spending is increasing globally year on year, the share of ecommerce is growing at a higher rate (11%), and traditional retailers cannot ignore it anymore.

Let’s look at some of the key retail attributes and how e-commerce players are pitted against the retailers:


From the table above, it seems that the game is even with both sides having certain advantages and disadvantages. The fact is that these companies are constantly innovating to get an edge over others. For e.g. Amazon’s recent move to establish a dedicated area in the P&G warehouse to supply consumer products has not gone well with physical retailers: P&G's Pact With Amazon Angers Target. On the other hand Walmart is copying Amazon to offer service like Click & Collect to its customers, who are not comfortable sharing their card details online. Outsiders may see this as battle for supremacy, but it is a good example of how competitive moves from either of players are leading the retail industry towards optimization, and a better customer experience.  

It is early to predict who will be the winner in this war between bits and bricks. Growing penetration of mobile devices and changing buying behaviour of young generation may have tilted the balance towards e-commerce players, but they can’t provide the human need to experience things before buying it, especially when buying an expensive item.

No comments:

Post a Comment